A Stronger Community.  Insurance with Impact.

Celebrating Our 90th Anniversary


Colligan’s value starts with our independence.  It’s an advantage that creates options and leads to trust and long term relationships.  As one of Indiana’s most established independent insurance agencies our personal and professional commitment continues to this day as we serve individuals, families, and businesses.    
We invite you to “Get A Quote” and see that we offer so much more.
Get a Quote


We care about our community and contribute to its prosperity.


We create high quality solutions through multiple carrier options.


We give professional advice, we are available, and we advocate for our clients.


The strength of our agency is based on the quality of our relationships.

First and foremost, a commitment to our clients wants and needs allows us to create intelligent solutions independent of any single carrier. This allows us to focus on a clients risks and provide value in an authentic, level headed, and competitive approach.

Secondly, we rely and recommend insurance carriers that have high quality products and services that serve our clients consistently.  Here is a sampling of some of the insurance carriers we work with.
Colligan Captive Agency Web/1-800-number
Multiple Carrier Options Yes No No
Relationship 90 Years & Going! Possible No
Customized Insurance Yes Limited Limited
Personalized Service Yes Limited / Call Center No
Change Carriers Yes No No
Claims Advocacy Yes Single Carrier Bias No
Objective Advice Yes Single Carrier Bias No