Since 1929 Colligan & Company has served to become your preferred agents, advisors, and neighbors. We give more investment into our clients than most firms desire or are able to give their clients. Our agency provides exceptional value for people and business leaders so that your interests are served when the unthinkable happens.
Auto
Home
Business
Life
Insurance Relationship
The strength of our agency is based on the quality of our relationships.
First and foremost, a commitment to our clients wants and needs allows us to create intelligent solutions independent of any single carrier. This allows us to focus on a clients risks and provide value in an authentic, level headed, and competitive approach.
Secondly, we rely and recommend insurance carriers that have high quality products and services that serve our clients consistently.
Alexandra McCavit
22:44 08 May 20
Dustin is the best! He made switching super easy and provided lots of good options. We saved money and got way better coverage!
Jonathan Wehrwein
13:56 07 May 20
Dustin was great to work with he was quick to respond to all my questions, able to save me money, and help me obtain the correct coverage for my... multiple dwellings during buying our new home as well as the home we are selling. I would highly recommend anyone to give them a call for a great insurance experience!read more
Gabriel Clark
22:56 04 Mar 20
These guys are Tops. Good people, full of integrity, big heart for customer service and investing in the community. No need to go anywhere else.... These guys care deeply about making sure insurance needs are met in a strategic way. As a business owner, they are my go to insurance team.read more
J- Killer-_-
20:11 03 Mar 20
Very helpful, very professional. Any questions we had we solved right away and every problem we had got fix almost immediately I would recommend them... to all my friendsread more
Brandon Bastian
19:30 27 Feb 20
Dustin Shirey was excellent to work with. He was able to pull quotes together from multiple locations for my auto and home owner's insurance. He... saved me over $200 a year from my previous insurance, which was the lowest cost I was able to find on my own. The best part? I even have more coverage than I previously did! I also love the fact that I have an agent I can work with every single time instead of a generic call center! Thanks for all the hard work Dustin!read more
Nick Toney
21:03 26 Feb 20
Great experience as we were looking to switch insurance companies. Jeremy met with me a few times and was willing to review our current policy and... provide a side by side comparison. He did a great job explaining everything and I never felt pressured into any kind of decision. I would highly recommend these guys!read more
Tim Howard
19:35 26 Feb 20
Jeremy and his team at Colligan & Company were extremely helpful to us in buying home owners insurance for our new home purchase. They were prompt in... getting us a competitive quote and educating us through the process. Would highly recommend them to anyone looking for homeowners insurance.read more
Luke Bone
21:18 04 Feb 20
I am a regular here and they have my insurance prepared exactly how I want it every time. Exceeds my expectations and greets me with a smile! I will... continue bringing my business here! Highly recommend!read more
James Nicholson
16:53 04 Nov 19
Knowledgeable and conscientious owners and staff. What a wonderful team to work with.
Jamie Molargik
12:56 01 Nov 19
I started shopping for a new insurance agent when my daughter started driving and my rates went through the roof and found Dustin Shirey. He was... very helpful and not pushy. I had been with my previous agent for 20 years so I was nervous about making the switch. It took me a few weeks to decide and at no point did I feel pressured. I would definitely recommend Dustin and his team.read more
James Couchman
18:43 23 Oct 19
Great people. Great care. Very personal. Colligan & Co. really looked after my family and helped us find the best insurance possible. I would highly... recommend them.read more
Colleen Fodrey
20:24 28 Mar 19
Jeremy is the best. Great prices and always has our back. He found us a great policy for our home and cars. We will be using him for all of our... insurance needs.read more
Brendon Maxwell
19:21 02 Feb 19
Colligan & Co. is an amazing company to work with. Through the course of 10+ years of being with them, my wife and I have had a few car wrecks and... they are the most attentive and supportive individuals you can imagine. I’ve also used them to insure our business in several capacities and the customer service is incredible. Anytime I need something or have a simple question, they are a quick phone call away, as opposed to calling an 800 number and waiting on hold to talk to someone who just doesn’t care because there is no relationship. I’d recommend Joel and Jeremy and the rest of the team to anyone!read more
Jarred Burns
14:40 25 Jan 19
Colligan & Company - Insurance Agency offers superior service for all your insurance needs. They work to get you the best price and truly customize... your plan to fit the needs of the entire family. I have been with this “local” company for several years and have always received the best customer service. They work hard to get you the best rate available to your family. Believe me when I say, from experience, you do not want to deal with national insurance agencies in times of need. You want to work with a local agency that actually has some sweat equity within the community. I have stopped in the office a few times just to ask some simple questions. Friendly staff, always accommodating. Would highly recommend for any insurance needs you may have!read more
Victoria Thrasher
12:32 25 Jan 19
Joel at Colligan & Company has been my agent for almost 12 years. He remembers me, is friendly, returns my calls and answers my questions promptly.... He is almost always available when I need something, and even if he’s not, the other people in the office are willing to try to help. I have made four claims (one house and three car) during this time period and they have all been taken care of quickly and covered things I did not expect. I really do love working with Joel and Colligan as a whole.read more
Robin Schroth
22:35 24 Jan 19
I cannot say enough about Jeremy and his Staff, they are always so welcoming and NEVER make you feel like an interruption. Not only did Jeremy take... the time to go through every part of my policies to make sure I understood exactly what I was doing, but he helped my budget as well. I have more/better coverage than before and paying a little less, we could all use that, right? If you are looking for a new company or just starting out, I would HIGHLY recommend Colligan & Company. They are very involved in the Community as well, which is a winner in my book, love to see local companies support each other.read more
Josh Sauder
21:53 24 Jan 19
Nothing but good experiences working with these folks. They give great advice and are just really good people. My one claim went very smoothly. You... cannot go wrong here. Thanks guys!read more
Insurance Blog
Insurance Auto Pilot Off | A Quick Assessment
If it has been a few years consider taking off the insurance autopilot with this quick assessment. Here are 10 easy questions you should know. Personal Does the insured value of my home accurately reflect the cost it would take to rebuild? [...]
The Independent Advantage
What’s the difference between a “State Farm” agency versus a local independent insurance agency? Let’s start from the beginning. State Farm is a captive insurance company that uses captive agencies. A captive agency can generally represent only one insurance company. Who are some captive insurance companies? Allstate, State Farm, Farmers, American Family, and 800-number companies [...]
Water Backup Claims
Your home is one of your most important assets. Homeowners insurance is meant to be a valuable tool for protecting that asset. It's downright overwhelming if you were to create a list of all the ways your home could be damaged. Even more troubling is that all homeowners insurance [...]