Colligan & Company is a full service property and casualty insurance agency serving people and business in Fort Wayne, Indiana and the surrounding communities.

We are local, independent, and trusted.

Local

Since 1929 Colligan & Company has served to become your preferred agency in Fort Wayne.  We are not an 800 number or serve an out of town interest.  We are your neighbors and cherish our community like you do.

Fort Wayne

Auto

home

business

Life

Independent

The strength of our agency is based on the quality of our relationships.

First, a commitment to our clients wants and needs allows us to create intelligent solutions independent of any single carrier. Our independence allows us to focus fully on a clients risks.  And because of this we can provide value in an authentic, level headed, and competitive approach.

Second, we recommend carriers that have high quality products and services.  In addition, to serve our clients as consistently as possible. Some of our top companies are Cincinnati, Westfield, Auto-Owners, State Auto, Safeco, Nationwide, and Hagerty.

Trusted

Trust is earned.  We wholeheartedly do not take the trust of our clients for granted.  Trust is foundational to our relationship. We earnestly work to protect it so that our clients can rest assured in selecting us to be on their team.

EXCELLENT rating
Based on 148 reviews
We worked with Dustin and were very happy with his assistance. He kept in close contact with us and quickly found appropriate coverage which was greatly appreciated.
Laura Bowker
Laura Bowker
2023-10-26
Dustin is a wonderful agent, he has always been there for me when I needed help with anything he is very patient with all my questions. He has always responded to me in a very timely manner either via text or email.
Kimberly Habegger
Kimberly Habegger
2023-10-26
Always kind, efficient
carolyn eaton
carolyn eaton
2023-09-01
I had multiple policies to change and everything went smoothly. I wouldn’t hesitate to refer Dustin to friends and family.
Sandra Hon
Sandra Hon
2023-07-27
I needed to review my current coverages and Dustin not only help me improve my coverage he saved me money. He was professional, quick, and provided great service. Would recommend him and the agency to anyone looking for help with their insurance needs.
Brian Lauber
Brian Lauber
2023-07-27
We switched to Colligan Insurance, with Mr. Dustin Shirey as our agent. transfer was very smooth & easy, with considerable savings for better coverage than with our old company.
Pete McDonald
Pete McDonald
2023-07-27
Dustin was on point with everything needed and did so quicker then I could have imagined. Thank you for the great servive.
Jonathan Hartnup
Jonathan Hartnup
2023-07-26
I have put off changing insurance over the years because normally a hassle, but Dustin made it easy! Received a quote promptly and was saving me so much money, can't believe I put it off for so long. Highly recommend Colligan & Company, talk to Dustin!
Jackie Smith
Jackie Smith
2023-04-26
As a new business owner I contacted my agent and asked for a in person meeting. He was accommodating and was very easy to work with. He exceeded my expectations by explaining in very simple terms how everything works. Even had a simplified explanation of the various coverages.
Kerry Ghent
Kerry Ghent
2023-04-25
Quick, flexibly, and informative. Loved working with Dusty! Will continue to do so
Michael Bade
Michael Bade
2023-04-25